
This post originally appeared in my weekly newsletter, BL&T (Borrowed, Learned, & Thought). Subscribe
“I don’t think people managers will have any value in the future. What I mean [by] people managers, people that only manage people. I think everyone’s going to have to be a hybrid people manager or manager IC, meaning they have to have contact with reality in some sense… So if you’re a lawyer, you’re just not managing people. You have to actually read the case law and you have to get involved.”
From Brian Chesky, Co-Founder/CEO of Airbnb, on Invest Like the Best [Podcast]
The lines between management and individual contributors are starting to blur. I remember my early management days, building out team structure and learning how to design career paths for the people on my team. For a long time I’d believed that a signal of success or seniority was overseeing other people, but that’s not right for everyone. You could have a really talented designer, for instance, who mentors others but never stops designing. Their craft and how they think is their value. Then there are people like me, who found that leadership was a passion and that helping get the best out of people was a skill I enjoyed developing.
With the way AI has entered our workplaces, I think a lot of this is breaking down in an interesting way. A couple of weeks ago, I wasn't feeling great (after the night in the ER with Mylo) and canceled most of my calls. I worked, but I didn’t feel up to talking all day. Instead, I ended up chatting with Claude the entire day. I was delegating work, giving feedback and thinking about the right questions to ask. With the calls out of the way, I could see how much of my time this takes up, and I do it every day.
This isn’t unique to me. Whether you’re a CEO leading a company or a junior designer supporting the team, you have to know how to manage AI, and it’s a lot like managing people. It’s like having a team of really smart direct reports. You get the most out of them the same way you get the most out of a team. You give clear direction, ask good questions, give and solicit feedback, and know what to delegate and what to keep. Managers have been practicing those skills for years. For that designer who never wanted to stop designing, it’s a new skill they have to learn, and they’re now doing some version of management every day, whether they think of it that way or not.
Middle management is evolving quickly, too. For a long time, a big part of the role was coordination: taking direction from leadership, turning it into work for the team, and reporting back on where things stood. For example, at an agency, part of an account manager’s job might have been consolidating client feedback before the team could act on it. That step isn’t needed anymore when anyone can pull it together in a few minutes. Managers aren’t going away. Someone still has to develop people, give them honest feedback and help them grow. But the coordination that used to fill their week is shrinking, and the managers who stay valuable will be the ones who stay close to the work and aren’t afraid to get their hands dirty.
We’re thinking about this a lot as we look at how our team is structured going forward, especially the role leadership plays in client work. It’s also changing how I think about the career paths I used to design. The choice between managing people and doing the work doesn’t hold up the way it used to.
What parts of how I work come from a team structure that doesn’t exist anymore?